Tuesday, April 17, 2012

Dallas Fed Fisher changed his vote on crisis interest rates after an unrecorded lunch break


Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas President Richard Fisher initially provided the only "No" vote on a motion before the Federal Open Market Committee at the height of the financial crisis—only to reverse his vote after an unrecorded lunch break according to a heavily redacted transcript of Fed documents released Monday afternoon. Here are some examples of motions that Fisher voted no:

p. 133
“The Federal Open Market Committee seeks monetary and financial conditions that will
foster price stability and promote sustainable growth in output. To further its long-run objectives,
the Committee in the immediate future seeks conditions in reserve markets consistent with reducing
the federal funds rate to an average of around 3 percent.”
Chairman Bernanke Yes
Vice Chairman Geithner Yes
President Fisher No
Governor Kohn Yes
Governor Kroszner Yes
Governor Mishkin Yes
President Pianalto Yes
President Plosser Yes
President Stern Yes
Governor Warsh Yes
CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. Thank you very much. We’ll take just a very quick recess for
the Governors to meet, and then we’ll come back for our presentation.
[Meeting recessed]
p. 156
“The Federal Open Market Committee seeks monetary and financial conditions that will
foster price stability and promote sustainable growth in output. To further its long-run
objectives, the Committee in the immediate future seeks conditions in reserve markets consistent
with reducing the federal funds rate to an average of around 2¼ percent.”
Chairman Bernanke Yes
Vice Chairman Geithner Yes
President Fisher No
Governor Kohn Yes
Governor Kroszner Yes
Governor Mishkin Yes
President Pianalto Yes
President Plosser No
President Stern Yes
Governor Warsh Yes
CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. Thank you. We are going to recess for the discount rate.

p. 253
[Redacted]
Chairman Bernanke Yes
First Vice President Cumming Yes
Governor Duke Yes
President Fisher No
Governor Kohn Yes
Governor Kroszner Yes
President Pianalto Yes
President Stern Yes
 Governor Warsh Yes
 CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. Thank you. Could we bring lunch back? Would that work?
 MS. DANKER. That doesn’t usually work well in a recorded session.
 CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. That doesn’t work well? All right. Let’s have half an hour for lunch.
MR. MADIGAN. The Board meeting, Mr. Chairman.
On p. 254 Fisher changed his vote:
CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. The Board meeting is adjourned. Hold on. The Board will go into my office. Everyone else, lunch. We will take a half hour break, and then we have just a few short items afterwards to complete. Okay? Thank you.
[Lunch break]
 CHAIRMAN BERNANKE. Let’s reconvene briefly for a couple of other items. On consideration, in order to maintain a united front with the Committee, President Fisher changed his vote to vote “yes” on the resolution
Two questions: 1. What did Bernanke say to Fisher for him to change his vote? 2. What was the vote on that was redacted that Fisher voted no on? 3. Why wasn't the conversation with the board in Bernanke's office recorded?




No comments: